Introduction
A cash balance plan is a type of defined benefit pension plan that offers participants a fixed account balance upon retirement. Contributions are made by the employer, who guarantees a minimum rate of return. The plan is portable, so employees can take their vested balance with them if they leave the company. Cash balance plans are becoming increasingly popular as a retirement savings option for high- earning professionals and business owners.
How cash balance pension plans work
Cash balance pension plans are a type of defined benefit plan, which means that they provide participants with a guaranteed retirement benefit based on a predetermined formula. Here is how they work:
-
Contribution:
The employer makes contributions to the plan, typically based on a percentage of the employee’s compensation. The contributions are pooled and invested by the plan administrator. -
Benefit accrual:
Each year, the participant’s account balance is credited with a” pay credit” and an” interest credit.” The pay credit is a percentage of the participant’s compensation, and the interest credit is a guaranteed rate of return set by the plan. The account balance grows over time as a result of these credits. -
Vesting:
Participants become vested in their account balance after a certain number of years of service, meaning they’ve anon-forfeitable right to the balance. -
Retirement benefit:
Upon retirement, the participant’s account balance is converted into a lifetime annuity or a lump- sum distribution. The annuity amount is based on the participant’s account balance, their age, and other factors specified in the plan document. -
Portability:
Participants can take their vested account balance with them if they leave the company before retirement, either as a lump sum or by rolling it over into another qualified retirement plan.
Benefits of cash balance pension plans
1.Predictable retirement income:
Cash balance plans provide a fixed account balance at retirement, which allows participants to predict their retirement income with greater certainty.2.Portability:
Employees can take their vested balance with them if they leave the company, unlike traditional defined benefit plans where benefits are usually forfeited if an employee leaves before retirement.3.Tax advantages:
Contributions to cash balance plans are tax- deductible for employers, and investment earnings grow tax-free. Participants also benefit from tax- deferred growth on their account balance.4.Higher contribution limits:
Cash balance plans allow for higher contribution limits than 401( k) plans, making them a valuable retirement savings tool for high- earning professionals and business owners.5.Reduced market risk:
Unlike 401( k) plans, cash balance plans aren’t directly affected by market fluctuations, which can provide a more stable retirement savings option for participants.Pros and cons of cash balance pension plans
Pros:
| Pros | Explanation |
| Predictable retirement income | Cash balance plans provide a fixed account balance at retirement, allowing participants to predict their retirement income with certainty. |
| Portability | Participants can take their vested account balance with them if they leave the company, unlike traditional defined benefit plans. |
| Tax advantages | Contributions to cash balance plans are tax-deductible for employers, and investment earnings grow tax-free. |
| Higher contribution limits | Cash balance plans allow for higher contribution limits than 401(k) plans, making them a valuable retirement savings tool for high earners. |
| Reduced market risk | Cash balance plans are not directly affected by market fluctuations, providing a more stable retirement savings option for participants. |
| Predictable retirement income | Cash balance plans provide a fixed account balance at retirement, allowing participants to predict their retirement income with certainty. |
| Portability | Participants can take their vested account balance with them if they leave the company, unlike traditional defined benefit plans. |
Cons:
| Cons | Explanation |
| Complexity | Cash balance plans can be more complex to understand than other retirement plans due to their unique features and terminology. |
| Limited investment options | Participants do not have control over the investments made by the plan administrator, limiting their investment options. |
| Required contributions | Employers are required to make contributions to the plan, which may be a disadvantage for smaller businesses or those with cash flow issues. |
| Lower flexibility in contributions for employees | Unlike defined contribution plans, participants cannot choose to contribute more or less to their accounts. |
| Benefit reductions in some cases due to age and tenure | Some cash balance plans have provisions that may reduce the retirement benefit for older or long-term employees, which may be a disadvantage. |
Key features of cash balance pension plans
Guaranteed retirement benefit Cash balance plans provide a guaranteed retirement benefit based on a formula specified in the plan document. Participants receive an account balance that grows over time with pay credits and interest credits.
Portability: Participants can take their vested account balance with them if they leave the company before retirement, either as a lump sum or by rolling it over into another qualified retirement plan.
Considerations for employees
Employees should consider the following factors when deciding whether to participate in a cash balance pension plan:
-
Plan features:
Understand the plan’s unique features, such as the interest crediting rate, vesting schedule, and distribution options. -
Investment options:
Review the plan’s investment options to ensure they align with your investment objectives and risk tolerance. -
Employer contributions:
Consider the employer’s contribution rate and any vesting requirements to assess the value of the plan. -
Portability:
Consider whether the plan allows for portability, which can be valuable if you plan to change jobs in the future. -
Retirement goals:
Determine if the plan aligns with your retirement goals and objectives, taking into account other retirement savings vehicles you may have. -
Risks:
Understand the risks associated with the plan, such as the potential for benefit reductions due to age or tenure. -
Professional advice:
Consider seeking professional advice from a financial advisor or retirement specialist to help make informed opinions about your retirement planning.
Considerations for employers
Employers should consider the following factors when deciding whether to adopt a cash balance pension plan:
-
Cost:
Consider the cost of establishing and administering the plan, including the costs of hiring a plan administrator and making employer contributions. -
Employee benefits:
Evaluate the potential benefits of the plan for employees, including its ability to attract and retain high- quality employees. -
Tax advantages:
Understand the tax advantages of the plan, including the ability to deduct employer contributions and tax- deferred investment earnings. -
Regulatory compliance:
Ensure compliance with federal and state regulations governing cash balance plans, including nondiscrimination testing and annual reporting requirements. -
Plan design:
Work with a plan administrator to design a plan that meets the needs of the employer and employees, including plan features such as vesting schedules and benefit formulas.
Conclusion
In conclusion, a cash balance plan is a hybrid retirement plan that offers a guaranteed benefit to employees based on a hypothetical account balance. It combines features of defined benefit and defined contribution plans, providing a more predictable retirement benefit while also offering flexibility and portability. Cash balance plans can be a valuable option for employees seeking a retirement plan that provides a guaranteed benefit with greater transparency and control over their savings.
